Skip to main content
Top

2024 | Book

Making the Rural Urban

Inter-Class Dynamics to Protect the Environment in a Gentrifying Rural Town in Colombia

insite
SEARCH

About this book

This book takes the small rural town of La Calera, in the outskirts of the Colombian capital of Bogotá, as a case study to analyze how residents from different social classes – wealthier ex-urban newcomers arriving to traditionally peasant and rural areas – interact to decide how nature will be used in the face of further urban expansion. Contrary to the conflicts in other gentrification cases, including those of “green” gentrification, this book shows how newcomers and longtimers in La Calera use environmental concerns to bridge social class rifts and push the state to provide water, public space, and decision-making power.

Residents see abundant ecological resources like water and land around them, but they do not have access to aqueducts, green public space or power over planning decisions affecting the distribution of these resources. As a response, and to challenge the state more effectively, newcomers and longtimers create inter-class alliances through what the author calls third nature: the way residents try to both protect and keep using existing ecological goods. To do so, despite high levels of class inequality, residents had a similar goal of protecting ecological resources around them by intervening in the physical and political landscapes against a state that induces scarcity, selectively enforcing environmental policies to the detriment of Calerunos.

As cities all around the Global South continue to grow, urban expansion posits a threat to the environment by transforming agricultural and protected areas into denser residential or touristic spaces. Moreover, as natural resources become scarcer in the face of climate change, inequality might further existing environmental privileges and vulnerabilities. By examining closely how Calerunos bridge class inequalities for environmental reasons, this case highlights processes that inform other gentrifying rural spaces around the world.

Table of Contents

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. Urbanizing the Mountains
Abstract
This chapter explores the socio-environmental effects of urbanization and rural-to-urban migration in Latin America, focusing on the case of La Calera, Colombia. In a region where urbanization rates are high, La Calera stands out for experiencing an unexpected trend of urban-to-rural migration. The transformation of agricultural and protected land into residential spaces raises questions about environmental justice and conflicting visions of nature. Despite class differences and competing interests, newcomers and longtimers in La Calera form coalitions based on shared goals of environmental protection and opposition to the state’s inconsistent actions. The chapter highlights the complex dynamics between different social classes and land uses, challenging traditional notions of peri-urban areas and emphasizing the need for closer study of the diverse urbanization processes in the Latin American countryside. It explores the concept of “rururbanization” to describe this in-between character of urban expansion, encompassing suburbanization and rural gentrification. Through an examination of interclass coalitions and negotiations with the state, the book offers insights into how people from different backgrounds can unite to protect nature and address the challenges of urban growth in the context of climate change.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Chapter 2. Layers of Nature: Population and Landscape Change
Abstract
This chapter explores the diverse uses of nature in La Calera, examining the concept of first, second, and third nature and their implications for longtime residents and newcomers. The productive use of nature, involving resource extraction like charcoal and limestone, has been traditionally carried out by the Calerunos themselves, who also engage in agriculture and cattle ranching. In contrast, newcomers seek to passively consume nature as a scenic backdrop and source of well-being. Despite their shared goal of preserving the ecological structure, newcomers inadvertently alter the landscape through housing development, creating a paradox. This interplay of different natures mirrors Cronon’s concept of first and second natures. The chapter also highlights the influence of zoning and environmental protection laws, as well as the active role of residents in shaping the landscape through their interventions and political involvement. As economic structures change, a complex dynamic emerges, wherein environmental preservation becomes essential for residents because of the state’s induced scarcity of environmental goods.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Chapter 3. The Greening Class and Its Influence in La Calera
Abstract
This text delves into the intricate microinteractions between newcomers and longtimers in La Calera. The complexity arises from the stark social class divide and the simultaneous need for social engagement and conflicting ideas about nature. These interactions are significantly influenced by environmental considerations, particularly the permitted uses of nature and their impact on the landscape. Class dynamics manifest in the imposition of “green” practices by privileged groups, despite longtimer communities’ need to exploit nature for their livelihoods. While tensions among neighbors are present, newcomers impose restrictions on social practices previously embraced by the long-time residents, driven by concrete concerns about environmental aesthetics and preservation. Paradoxically, newcomers, despite their own landscape-altering housing developments, perceive themselves as protectors of the area’s first nature attributes while constraining second nature interventions. Acknowledging their position of power, newcomers adopt a paternalistic stance, aiming to instruct longtimers on “good” practices, though such efforts are met with resistance and demands for compensation. Notably, interactions between groups can also be egalitarian and functional, exemplified by pre-k programs and employment relationships. These microlevel symbolic and community connections serve as a foundation for environmental preservation and are echoed in macrolevel discussions involving state involvement. Shared ecological goals have the potential to transcend class differences, animosity, and condescension, facilitating coalition-building for environmental concerns. Demand for the enforcement of environmental protection laws empowers residents to shape the natural landscape while grappling with infrastructure challenges, such as water scarcity.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Chapter 4. Waterscapes and the Paradox of Growth
Abstract
This chapter explores the paradox of growth faced by La Calera, where infrastructure development requires a critical mass of users to sustain itself, but an increase in users strains the capacity of existing infrastructure, resulting in shortages and coverage issues. The urbanization of La Calera has transformed it into a city-like neighborhood without the necessary infrastructure to support its population, leading to a dearth of desired first nature features and insufficient second nature interventions. Residents perceive this situation through the lens of environmental justice, as they witness the presence of water sources and community aqueducts while being wary of the state’s intervention to privatize and reduce their control over water governance. In response, longtimers and newcomers forge a shared third nature, aiming to protect the waterscape while demanding improved water services from the state. These efforts give rise to new coalitions focused on self-management of existing aqueducts and legal actions against the state. Interestingly, these coalitions transcend class differences, with residents leveraging each other’s resources and knowledge to improve water access. La Calera stands as a counterexample to infrastructure development in Latin American slums and urban peripheries, where there is homogeneity in class composition. Residents in La Calera employ legal mechanisms and popular actions to confront the state as they seek to obtain water services within the bounds of the law.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Chapter 5. The Unfulfilled Promises of San Rafael Park
Abstract
This chapter explores the dynamics between third nature and scarcity in abundance through the case of land in La Calera. Specifically, it focuses on the San Rafael Ecological Park project, which led to a coalition among longtimers and newcomers against the state. While both groups supported the park’s objective of redistributing environmental privileges, they opposed the design process, feeling that their voices were not considered. They sought to expand the concept of third nature beyond restrictive boundaries imposed by the state, advocating for ecotourism and other human-nonhuman interactions that would benefit both the economy and the environment. Residents resorted to various mechanisms to ensure their own visions of third nature were included. Despite initial inclusion, the realization of their proposals was uncertain, requiring the intervention of a court to halt the project. This legal action highlighted environmental justice concerns and the right to a healthy environment.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Chapter 6. Wardens of the Mountains Against Urbanization
Abstract
This chapter explores the dynamics of “just green enough” coalitions in rural areas experiencing urban expansion, focusing on the planning meetings in La Calera. The democratized planning instruments in Colombia allow various actors to influence development and planning processes. In La Calera, residents from different social positions came together, bridging the gap between newcomers and longtimers, to address common planning issues. Their shared vision centered around protecting the ecosystem through human interventions, such as environmental protection laws. The planning meetings provided an effective platform for residents to engage with the state and make their voices heard. Unlike other areas where tensions between residents arise, La Calera residents successfully halted a social housing complex driven by land speculation, initiated discussions on a more redistributive land tax scheme, and had their meeting demands met. Their unity was driven by the desire to preserve the green character of La Calera and prevent further urban growth in rural areas. This shared goal allowed them to present their demands to the state collectively, leveraging strength in numbers to challenge zoning regulations that facilitated urban expansion.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Chapter 7. Nature’s Identity Crisis
Abstract
This chapter explores the identity crisis faced by La Calera, a rural town in Latin America, as it navigates the tension between its agricultural and mining past and the encroaching urbanization. The commodification of nature for aesthetic and productive purposes has led to environmental and social pressures on the town. The environmental pressure stems from the increasing demand for infrastructure and public goods due to the influx of newcomers, coupled with the selective enforcement of environmental laws that favor corporations over residents. The social pressure arises from the differing interests of newcomers, who seek aesthetic enjoyment of nature, and longtimers, who rely on nature for material goods and livelihoods. Despite these tensions, residents of La Calera share a metaphysical connection to nature, which forms the basis for potential coalitions in environmental planning. The chapter also explores the concept of “third nature,” which encompasses the actions taken by residents to protect and preserve nature in the face of urbanization. The unequal distribution of environmental goods and bads and the power struggles among different social hierarchies contribute to environmental inequalities. However, the integration of residents through functional, symbolic, and social interactions creates opportunities for collective action in addressing ecological concerns.
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Backmatter
Metadata
Title
Making the Rural Urban
Author
Sebastián Felipe Villamizar-Santamaría
Copyright Year
2024
Electronic ISBN
978-3-031-58335-3
Print ISBN
978-3-031-58334-6
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-58335-3