Skip to main content

2024 | OriginalPaper | Buchkapitel

15. Closed-Loop Supply Chains: A Strategic Overview

verfasst von : James D. Abbey, V. Daniel R. Guide Jr, Xichen Sun

Erschienen in: Sustainable Supply Chains

Verlag: Springer International Publishing

Aktivieren Sie unsere intelligente Suche, um passende Fachinhalte oder Patente zu finden.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

Managers that consider a closed-loop supply chain just another environmental initiative need to update their thinking. Modern firms that use closed-loop supply chains as a competitive strategy receive many benefits—particularly higher profitability and control over a product’s entire lifecycle. In fact, the market for multiple lifecycle products continues to grow, with estimates holding that remanufactured product sales exceed $100 billion per year. As a result of analyzing the ever-growing remanufacturing sector through years of working with managers in numerous industries, various levers and themes surrounding effective closed-loop supply chain strategies became apparent. This chapter presents these findings and shows how firms in multiple industries experienced both successes and failures of their closed-loop supply chain strategies, recently also synonymously called circular economy strategies.

Sie haben noch keine Lizenz? Dann Informieren Sie sich jetzt über unsere Produkte:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Fußnoten
1
The global remanufacturing market has been growing. Current estimates of the remanufactured products market in the U.S. come from the United States International Trade Commission (USITC) report on remanufactured goods. See “USITC. 2012. Remanufactured goods: an overview of the U.S. and global industries, markets, and trade. Public report, U.S. International Trade Commission accessible at http://​www.​usitc.​gov/​publications/​332/​pub4356.​pdf.” The European Remanufacturing Network estimates that the remanufacturing market in Europe will grow to €90 billion by 2030, tripling the €30 billion market in 2015 (https://​www.​remanufacturing.​eu/​)
 
2
Corporate social responsibility continues to generate much debate about the role of a corporation as a good citizen. For an excellent discussion of such issues, see “Carroll, A. B. 1999. Corporate social responsibility evolution of a definitional construct. Business & Society 38(3): 268–295.”
Additionally, for firms less interested in internally promoting environmental initiatives, legislative mandates regarding environmental performance and impact are particularly prevalent in the European Union with the waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE: http://​ec.​europa.​eu/​environment/​waste/​weee/​legis_​en.​htm) and reduction of hazardous substances (RoHS: http://​ec.​europa.​eu/​environment/​waste/​rohs_​eee/​index_​en.​htm). Both laws seek to control environmental impact. Though the E.U. was among the first to enact such laws, Japan (http://​www.​env.​go.​jp/​en/​policy/​) and Australia (http://​www.​environment.​gov.​au/​about-us/​legislation) have followed with similar legislation aimed at curbing environmental impact.
Though much of the strict recycling mandates legislation has not occurred within the U.S., multinational firms already maintain product portfolios that meet the ambitious requirements. Should the legislative programs continue to expand throughout the world, firms holding such product portfolios may hold a competitive advantage over competitors who currently do not meet the requirements of such legislation. Various recent works address the issue of environmental legislation and product take-back. For several such works, see “Atasu, A. and L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2010. “Environmental Legislation Regarding Product Take-Back and Recovery” in ‘Closed-Loop Supply Chains,’ Eds. M. Ferguson, G. Souza. Taylor and Francis.” and works tailored to the extended producer responsibility for electronics waste and durable goods “Atasu, A., R. Subramanian. 2012. Extended Producer Responsibility for E-Waste: Individual or Collective Responsibility? Production and Operations Management 21(6): 1042–1059,” “Alev, I., Agrawal, V. V., & Atasu, A. 2020. Extended Producer Responsibility for Durable Products. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 22(2): 364–382.”
 
3
If the concept of a closed-loop supply chain is unfamiliar, multiple resources can provide guidance and insights. For example, see “Guide, V.D.R. Jr., and Van Wassenhove, L.N. 2003. “Business Aspects of Closed-Loop Supply Chains” in Guide, V.D.R. Jr., and Van Wassenhove, L.N. (eds.), Business Aspects of Closed-Loop Supply Chains Exploring the Issues. Pittsburgh: Carnegie Mellon University Press.” Also, see “Ferguson, M.E. and Souza, G.C. 2010. Closed-Loop Supply Chains New Developments to Improve the Sustainability of Business Practices. Boca Raton: CRC Press.”
For some readers, perhaps the circular economy is a more familiar concept as an alternative to closed-loop supply chains. See “Atasu, A., Dumas, C. and Van Wassenhove, L.N., 2021. The Circular Business Model. Harvard Business Review, 99(4): 72–81” for more information on circular economy strategies.
 
4
For a discussion of the continuing challenges in closed-loop supply chains, see “Guide, V. D. R. and L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2009. The evolution of closed-loop supply chain research. Operations Research 57(1): 10–18.”
 
5
The rate of false failure returns can vary widely by the nature of the product and industry. As a prime example in the consumer electronics industry, Hewlett-Packard experienced false failure returns rates as high as 80% of all inkjet printer returns. On the other hand, Bosch false failure return rates at a vastly lower 2% of all power drill returns. For more information, see “Ferguson, M., V.D.R. Guide, Jr., G.C. Souza. 2006. Supply chain coordination for false failure returns. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management 8(4): 376–393.”
 
6
The National Retail Federation offers free, detailed reports on returns. For recent reports, such as the 2021 report noted, see https://​cdn.​nrf.​com/​sites/​default/​files/​2022-01/​Customer%20​Returns%20​in%20​the%20​Retail%20​Industry%20​2021.​pdf
 
7
Abdulla, H., Ketzenberg, M. and Abbey, J.D., 2019. Taking stock of consumer returns: A review and classification of the literature. Journal of Operations Management, 65(6), pp. 560–605.
 
8
Ketzenberg, M.E., Abbey, J.D., Heim, G.R. and Kumar, S., 2020. Assessing customer return behaviors through data analytics. Journal of Operations Management, 66(6), pp. 622–645.
 
9
Abdulla, H., Abbey, J.D. and Ketzenberg, M., 2022. How consumers value retailer’s return policy leniency levers: An empirical investigation. Production and Operations Management, 31(4), pp. 1719–1733.
 
10
Shang, G., Ferguson, M.E. and Galbreth, M.R., 2019. Where should I focus my return reduction efforts? Empirical guidance for retailers. Decision Sciences, 50(4), pp. 877–909.
 
11
Shang, G., McKie, E.C., Ferguson, M.E. and Galbreth, M.R., 2020. Using transactions data to improve consumer returns forecasting. Journal of Operations Management, 66(3), pp. 326–348.
 
12
For an examination of seeing returns as a means to profit, see: “Abbey, J., Ketzenberg, M. and Metters, R., 2018. A more profitable approach to product returns. MIT Sloan Management Review, 60(1), pp. 1–6.”
 
13
The Remanufacturing Industries Council’s (https://​remancouncil.​org/​) gives an in-depth look at remanufacturing from various industry perspectives. In particular, the website provides details about remanufacturing processes and the resulting environmental benefits.
 
14
For an in-depth look at the practice of “seeding,” which means selling a new product under the guise of being previously used and remanufacturing, see: “Abbey, J.D., Geismar, H.N. and Souza, G.C., 2019. Improving remanufacturing core recovery and profitability through seeding. Production and Operations Management, 28(3), pp. 610–627.”
 
15
For an examination of issues in production planning and control in the engine portion of remanufacturing, see “Guide, V.D.R., Jr. 2000. Production planning and control for remanufacturing: industry practice and research needs. Journal of Operations Management 18(4): 467–483.” For detailed information about the issues related to grading the quality of cores acquired through the front-end processes of product acquisition management, see “Ferguson, M., V.D.R. Guide, Jr., E. Koca, and G.S. Souza. 2009. The value of quality grading in remanufacturing. Production and Operations Management 18(3): 300–314.”
 
16
For an overview of the current state of market-based literature for remanufactured products and pricing structures, and market segments, see, “Abbey, J.D., Meloy, M.G., Blackburn, J. and Guide Jr., V.D.R., 2015. Consumer markets for remanufactured and refurbished products. California Management Review, 57(4), pp. 26–42.”
 
17
This figure is adapted from, “Abbey, J.D., V.D.R. Guide Jr. 2012. “Closed-Loop Supply Chains” in T. Bansal, A. Hoffman, (eds.), Oxford Handbook on Business and the Natural Environment. New York: Oxford University Press, 290–309.”
 
18
For further information on the reduce, reuse, and recycle (3R) hierarchy, see the Environmental Protection Agency’s website at http://​www.​epa.​gov/​recycle
 
19
See “Atasu, A., V.D.R. Guide, Jr., L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2009. “So what if remanufacturing cannibalizes new product sales?” California Management Review 52: 56–76.”
 
20
For additional insights into how to operate in a competitive core acquisition market, see “Guide, V. D. R., R.H. Teunter, and L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2003. Matching demand and supply to maximize profits from remanufacturing. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management 5: 303–316.”
 
21
For a detailed look at the nature of such challenges related to marginal value of time in fast moving industries such as consumer electronics, see “Guide, V. D. R., G.C. Souza, L.N. Van Wassenhove, and J.D. Blackburn. 2006. Time value of commercial product returns. Management Science 52: 1200–1214.” For potential solutions to maximize profits based on the nature of the industry’s marginal value of time, see “Blackburn, J.D., V.D.R. Guide, G.C. Souza, and L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2004. Reverse Supply Chains for Commercial Returns. California Management Review 46: 6–22.”
 
22
The Xerox Corporation has been a world leader in remanufacturing systems at their Webster, New York manufacturing/remanufacturing hybrid facilities. In both popular press and academic research, Xerox stands out as an exemplar of environmentally friendly closed-loop supply chain systems. Xerox works diligently from the design phase forward to recycle and remanufacture their equipment with great success in energy, materials, and waste reduction. For instance, in 2020, Xerox’s remanufacturing operations diverted over 6030 metric tons of waste from landfills. See a recent corporate sustainability report at https://​www.​xerox.​com/​en-us/​about/​corporate-social-responsibility
 
23
Reverse supply chain design for consumer products remains a persistent issue for many firms. For a detailed discussion of viable solutions in consumer product industries, see the California Management Review article, “Blackburn, J.D., V.D.R. Guide, G.C. Souza, and L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2004. Reverse Supply Chains for Commercial Returns. California Management Review 46: 6–22.”
 
24
Much recent research focuses on the need for better understanding of design for remanufacturing and reuse. Many resources exist for those interested in the engineering side of design such as the Rochester Institute of Technology’s Center for Remanufacturing and Resource Recovery (http://​www.​rit.​edu/​gis/​remanufacturing/​). For an excellent summary of research on the topic of product design in a CLSC, see “Bras, B. 2010. “Product Design Issues” in Ferguson, M.E. and Souza, G.C. (eds.), Closed-Loop Supply Chains New Developments to Improve the Sustainability of Business Practices. Boca Raton: CRC Press.” Finally, for general resources on remanufacturing, see the Remanufacturing Industries Council website at http://​remancouncil.​org/​
 
25
The major impetus for this chapter and framework for understanding strategies for reuse through remanufacturing comes from ongoing research found in the manuscript, “Abbey, J.D. and Guide Jr., V.D.R., 2018. A typology of remanufacturing in closed-loop supply chains. International Journal of Production Research, 56(1–2), pp. 374–384.”
 
26
Reclaiming rare earth and other precious metals from electronics products has been an issue for decades. For a review of issues related to such reclamation, see “Cui, J., and E. Forssberg. 2003. Mechanical recycling of waste electric and electronic equipment: a review. Journal of Hazardous Materials 99: 243–263.”
 
27
Delta Airlines and Lufthansa continue to generate significant cost savings and profits through repair and refurbishment of both their own equipment and equipment for other airlines. For details on Delta Airlines’ continued strategy of extending lifecycles of aircraft, see “Carry, Susan. 2012. “Delta Flies New Route to Profits: Older Jets,” The Wall Street Journal November 16, 2012.” Lufthansa Technik AG actively markets their commercial airline refurbishment services for all levels of maintenance, overhaul, engines, components, aircraft systems, and more. For details, see Lufthansa website at https://​www.​lufthansa-technik.​com/​base-maintenance
 
28
For a discussion of such issues of risk perceptions and ambiguity tolerance among consumers, see: “Abbey, J.D., Kleber, R., Souza, G.C. and Voigt, G., 2019. Remanufacturing and consumers’ risky choices: Behavioral modeling and the role of ambiguity aversion. Journal of Operations Management, 65(1), pp. 4–21.,” and “Abbey, J.D., Kleber, R., Souza, G.C. and Voigt, G., 2017. The role of perceived quality risk in pricing remanufactured products. Production and Operations Management, 26(1), pp. 100–115.”
 
29
As noted before, the E.U., Japan, and Australia have all moved toward increasing legislative mandates for recycling and waste stream reduction. This increasing legislative pressure has also come to the U.S. in the form of California’s recycling laws aimed to curbing electronics and other waste (http://​www.​calrecycle.​ca.​gov/​recycle/​)
 
30
Two studies shed light on the nature of consumer perceptions of multiple lifecycle products. The first study delves into the various factors that influence how consumers perceive multiple lifecycle (e.g., remanufactured) products (see, “Abbey, J. D., et al. 2015. Remanufactured Products in Closed-Loop Supply Chains for Consumer Goods. Production and Operations Management 24(3): 488–503.”). An even more recent work examines how various consumer segments emerge with a sizeable portion—upwards of 35%—of consumers refusing to consider a remanufactured product of any kind (see, “Abbey, J.D., Blackburn, J.D. and Guide Jr., V.D.R., 2015. Optimal pricing for new and remanufactured products. Journal of Operations Management, 36, pp. 130–146.”).
 
31
Fear of new product sales cannibalization when offering a remanufactured product has been a long-standing source of opposition for remanufacturing at many firms. For a nice discussion of such opposition and strategies to handle common issues with potential cannibalization, see “Atasu, A., V.D.R. Guide, Jr., L.N. Van Wassenhove. 2009. So what if remanufacturing cannibalizes new product sales? California Management Review 52: 56–76.”
 
32
Pinar Martin has released a book on the various levels of remanufacturing strategy as well as a scholarly paper on the topic. For those interested in the more managerially oriented materials, see “Martin, P. 2010. Remanufacturing as a Supply Chain Strategy: Business Models and Case Studies. Dusseldorf, Germany: VDM Verlag.” For those interested in the technical details, see “Martin, P., V.D.R. Guide, and C.W. Craighead. 2010. Supply chain sourcing in remanufacturing operations: an empirical investigation of remake versus buy. Decision Sciences 41: 301–324.”
 
33
For a detailed look at Dell’s outsourced remanufacturing/refurbishing strategy, see “Vitasek, K., Ledyard, M., & Manrodt, K. 2013. Vested outsourcing: five rules that will transform outsourcing. Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 185–198.”
 
34
Caterpillar is proud of their industry-leading remanufacturing and reuse systems. To say that remanufacturing and reuse is a core competence of Caterpillar would be an understatement. In any given year, Caterpillar reuses more than 120 million pounds of iron alone. For a detailed look at Caterpillar’s remanufacturing operations, see their website at http://​www.​caterpillar.​com/​en/​company/​sustainability/​remanufacturing.​html
 
35
For a fascinating look at the adverse and even beneficial consequences of third-party remanufacturing, see “Agrawal, V., A. Atasu, K. van Ittersum. 2015. Remanufacturing, third party competition, and the perceived value of new products. Management Science 61(1): 60–72.,” as well as the challenge of selling assortments to third-party remanufacturers in “Mutha, A., Bansal, S. and Guide, V.D.R., 2019. Selling Assortments of Used Products to Third-Party Remanufacturers. Production and Operations Management, 28(7), pp. 1792–1817.”
 
36
For a look at the broad range of products—some of which are only available in remanufactured form—that Cardone Industries remanufacturers, see their website at https://​www.​cardone.​com/​
 
37
For example, as the leading remanufacturer in the industry, Xerox has adapted its business model to lease photocopiers to customers. Through leasing, the company guarantees that 100% of the equipment is taken back at the end of their leasing terms for remanufacturing or parts recycling (https://​www.​xerox.​com/​corporate-social-responsibility/​2018/​environment/​circular-economy.​html)
 
38
For an excellent discussion of coordination issues incumbent on a firm choosing to servicize, see: “Mutha, A., Bansal, S. and Guide, V.D.R., 2022. What servicizing demands of a company: The need for inter-functional coordination. Journal of Operations Management 68:408–420.”
 
40
For more information about Caterpillar’s Job Site Solutions, see https://​www.​cat.​com/​en_​US/​support/​operations/​jobsite-solutions.​html
 
41
For a full documentation of the Evergreen Services Agreement at Interface, see “Oliva R, Quinn J. 2003 Interface’s Evergreen Services Agreement. HBS Case 603–112, Harvard Business School, Boston.”
 
42
As an example, the white goods manufacturer Gorenje struggled to implement the leasing-and-remanufacturing model, as the total cost of ownership for customers to lease a washing machine could be 40%–100% higher than that of purchasing one owing to substantial repair costs. For more information on Gorenje’s journey toward closing the loop, see “van Loon, P., Van Wassenhove, L. N., & Mihelic, A. 2022. Designing a Circular Business Strategy: 7 Years of Evolution at a Large Washing Machine Manufacturer. Business Strategy and the Environment, 31(3): 1030–1041.”
 
43
Rent The Runaway, an e-commerce platform that provides fast fashion rentals, is one of the retailers pursuing clothes renting strategies. Unfortunately, a recent study has revealed that the rental model aiming at environmental sustainability can result in even higher environmental impact than the basic use-and-dispose model. See “Levänen, J., Uusitalo, V., Härri, A., Kareinen, E., & Linnanen, L. 2021. Innovative recycling or extended use? Comparing the global warming potential of different ownership and end-of-life scenarios for textiles. Environmental Research Letters, 16(5): 054069.”
 
44
For insight into the issues of accounting, financials, and inter-functional issues, see: “Mutha, A., Bansal, S. and Guide, V.D.R., 2021. Managing the inter-functional tension between accounting-and financial-profits in remanufacturing multiple-usecycle products. Production and Operations Management, 30(9), pp. 2993–3014.”
 
Literatur
Zurück zum Zitat Blass V, Ashkenazy A, Chebach TC (2024) Sustainable non-renewable materials management. In: Bouchery Y, Corbett CJ, Fransoo JC (eds) Sustainable supply chains: a research-based textbook on operations and strategy. Springer, Cham Blass V, Ashkenazy A, Chebach TC (2024) Sustainable non-renewable materials management. In: Bouchery Y, Corbett CJ, Fransoo JC (eds) Sustainable supply chains: a research-based textbook on operations and strategy. Springer, Cham
Zurück zum Zitat Gillai B, Lee HL, Rammohan SV (2024) Improving social and environmental performance in global supply chains. In: Bouchery Y, Corbett CJ, Fransoo JC (eds) Sustainable supply chains: a research-based textbook on operations and strategy. Springer, Cham Gillai B, Lee HL, Rammohan SV (2024) Improving social and environmental performance in global supply chains. In: Bouchery Y, Corbett CJ, Fransoo JC (eds) Sustainable supply chains: a research-based textbook on operations and strategy. Springer, Cham
Zurück zum Zitat Huang N, Atasu A (2024) Operational implications of environmental regulation. In: Bouchery Y, Corbett CJ, Fransoo JC (eds) Sustainable supply chains: a research-based textbook on operations and strategy. Springer, Cham Huang N, Atasu A (2024) Operational implications of environmental regulation. In: Bouchery Y, Corbett CJ, Fransoo JC (eds) Sustainable supply chains: a research-based textbook on operations and strategy. Springer, Cham
Metadaten
Titel
Closed-Loop Supply Chains: A Strategic Overview
verfasst von
James D. Abbey
V. Daniel R. Guide Jr
Xichen Sun
Copyright-Jahr
2024
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-45565-0_15

Premium Partner